Why Latin America?

It’s a question that I’ve asked myself a lot. I suppose in a sense pre-emptively. I don’t think anyone else has ever really questioned my interest in the region. I mean why would they? I’m clearly Argentinean (at least phenotypically) and I can read, speak and teach Spanish. Well, when I ask myself the question, I find it’s less about confirming for myself why I should be interested in Latin America, but more about how I can explain to others why they should be. You see, the truth is, while I can’t deny that I do have some vested interested in terms of a cultural connection to the region, my interest is also academic. While it’s easy to explain why I might be interested in the literature, music and history of a country like Argentina that a parent was raised in and that I have visited countless times, it’s not as straightforward to justify my interest in countries as diverse as Mexico, Colombia, Peru and Brazil. Indeed, it would be quite unthinkable to suggest that someone from France be interested in Polish cultural production because of their heritage.

But that’s where that term. Latin America, comes in. All encompassing, imperially-coined, Latin America swoops in like a condor and erases all the inconveniences of heterogeneity; socially, culturally and geographically. It might seem facetious to point out that the aforementioned countries are incredibly distinct, but that’s much of what troubles the study of Latin America in the English-speaking world, that such an assumption exists until it is challenged. While equally homogenizing tendencies exist when approaching other regions that have historically been underrepresented and undervalued in the English-speaking world such as Asia and Africa, Latin America nevertheless continues to stand unique as a site that can be conceived of as completely monolithic while simultaneously inspiring and evoking so many contradictory feelings and values to different. Even before it was Latin America, the “New World” has acted in equal parts as mirror, sponge and laboratory for European conceptions of society and culture, paradoxically because of its intrinsic differences.

This is a region that is presented as, on the one-hand, a lawless and exotic jungle run by mercenaries and drug cartels, and on the other as a devout Catholic bastion. It has been subjected in equal measure to both military dictatorships pushing neoliberal economic reforms backed by the United States and authoritarian socialist governments nationalizing industries and antagonizing intellectuals. Vibrant, experimental and sophisticated works of literature from around the continent have caught the attention of publishing houses and were translated and marketed in the terms of a metaphorical explosion, an onomatopoeic “boom” that in its very nomenclature suggests that it emerged from nothing, and like Latin America itself, been hit with the brush of ‘magical realism,’ all the while telenovelas, tango and cumbia entertain the masses. There are entire indigenous populations that self-identify as “indios” because of Colombus’ mistaken assumption. Countries that achieved their independence in the late 18th and early 19th centuries from Spain and Portugal have only recently been categorized as postcolonial, and cities with populations that dwarf most European equivalents are considered provincial.

It is a region of extremes and paradoxes, and that is precisely why it interests me. As foreign and exotic as it may seem, the diversity of conditions, peoples and politics present in Latin America mean that in many ways it is the perfect historical subject to make sense of our own societies. As many intellectual from Latin America have historically identified, despite the richness of indigenous cultures, Latin America as it is understood now is inextricably connected to the destiny of other European countries. While the problems of Latin America and its individual countries are unique, they are a litmus test and oracle for those that occur in the so-called “centre.” Growing inequality as a result of monopolies, populist politics and Authoritarian strongmen waging battles against imagined elites while lining their own pockets with impunity, ecological destruction for the sake unsustainable industries. What was once unique to the so-called Banana Republics is now shared with the English-speaking countries that were bank-rolling the dictators. The economic collapses of many Latin American countries in the late 1990s as a result of neoliberal reforms can be read as a clear precursor to the 2008 global financial crisis.

At the end of the day, these are only a few arguments that I think can be made to answer the question, and I understand that they may not be convincing to people who aren’t already interested in the region. As a final appeal, all I can say is that Latin America’ s diversity, problems and cultural productions are human. I hesitate to say universal, because it is reductionist to claim so, but human, in that, even acknowledging the uniqueness of Latin America as a region, we don’t exceptionalise it, as has been done for so many years to make it appear exotic and unattainable. We can learn about Latin America, both for the aspects that make it different from contemporary English-speaking countries, and for the ones that make it familiar.

Leave a Reply