In light of the fact that the most traction I’ve ever received on the internet was this post,
I thought it appropriate that my debut piece should be this piece of creative non-fiction.
I walked through Hyde Park almost every day last year, on the way home from work. I’d see them there sometimes with their banners and signs unfurled. Falun Dafa is Good. Truthfulness. Compassion. Tolerance. And they, in yellow nylon jackets and hats waving at the passers-by, their hands full of fliers and smiles plastered on their faces or meditating in the lotus position in the grass.
You’d be forgiven for mistaking the practitioners in the park for just about any other group of wellness gurus. Harmless and peaceful. I’m sure that most people walking past do anyway, barely sparing them a glance, busy in their suits heading to the Westfield or St. James. But they might catch a glance of another sign on the opposite side of the footpath. Black and white, tucked in the corner, looking far more serious juxtaposed against the calming blue hues and yellow text of its neighbours, posing a rather serious and seemingly bizarre question; “Persecuted in China?” and then maybe, just maybe their curiosity is piqued and they walk up to one of the smiling faces and take a leaflet. Stop organ harvesting.
Other days they don’t even bother trying to hide their intentions. They have a full table set-up, and its on display there in big block letters. Killed for their organs. Say no to the CCP. Mindfulness and prayer and meditation are on the back fence, out of sight on those days. They’re militant, handing out clipboards and inviting the passers-by to sign petitions. And why not? What’s the harm? Especially now that we’re all hearing about what’s happening to the Uyghurs in Xinjiang, or the students in Hong Kong.
The first time that I saw them standing there, however, it brought back memories of the Star Ferry in Tsim Tsa Tsui. They were the same sort of fliers but in Cantonese, and I was about three years old. I remember reaching out for one and then, inexplicably, knocking them out of the man’s hands and scattering them across the pavement. To this day I don’t know what compelled me to do it. Was it the fact that people walking past had steered clear or spat at their feet? Regardless, I can still replay the moment in my head as clearly as if I were experiencing it for the first time. My mother’s shock, and the man looking down at me completely surprised. I still feel the shame of it. Mum asking me why I would do that and to pick them up for him, and me sheepishly apologising. He was smiling the whole time. At me. At my mother. It somehow made it all worse that he had forgiven me. It made my skin crawl.
It would be years later when I learnt what it all meant. I would have been seventeen or eighteen at that point and still wasn’t all that worried about the mainland. Any fears I had about what the government would do in the future were still abstract, looming shadows without shape, 2047’s problem, not ours. I was walking around Causeway Bay with my best friend, just outside of the SoGo department building, on the way to a movie, or just to talk while window shopping in Ikea or HMV or to get a coffee at Starbucks. All across the rails on the street, and hanging off of the lips of buildings, were warring slogans. Boycott the evil Falun Gong. Justice will prevail. Backwards swastikas in their original Buddhist context. Attention piqued, I asked her the fuss was about, who the Falun Gong really were. I’d heard the name of course, but she spoke Cantonese, you see, and her father was a local politician, so I trusted her perspective. “Think Scientology meets tai chi. They’re fucking weird man. I don’t know if I’d call them evil though you hear stories. The signs were put up by some pro-Beijing youth group since they were kicked out of China. It’s just fucked up all round.”
The truth about the Falun Gong is hard to pinpoint, because it’s such a nexus for disinformation and proselytising. The competing actors, the organisation itself, and the Chinese Communist Party that outlawed it, are locked in a constant cycle of denouncing the other’s evil intentions. What is undeniable, however, are the actions, practices and organisations that they endorse and champion.
Like a cult, they encourage you to detach yourself from your earthly tethers such as your family and occupation so that you can become just like “Master Li,” a man so spiritual he can reportedly walk through walls and levitate. Followers are often invited to live on compounds where they are required to work and their children forced to participate in dance lessons so as to funnel them into Shen Yun performance troupes, with allegations made about grooming and other abusive behaviours. They explicitly forbid homosexual activity and engage in practices of conversion therapy. Falun Gong teaches also, that by following its teachings, one’s body will become completely able to heal itself, and as such followers with chronic conditions are frequently influenced and in some cases coerced into abandoning their medicinal regiments with often fatal results.
And then, of course, there is the Epoch Times, their far-less divine or peaceful propaganda wing. Although they routinely deny it, there is copious evidence that demonstrates that Falun Gong practitioners comprise the bulk of the editorial staff of the organisation in its various offices across the world. It is an organisation so extremely right-wing and brazen that even Facebook has banned it; for creating fake accounts to artificially inflate its popularity and advertise its contents organically. In a globally coordinated effort, the Epoch Times sparked recent controversy by delivering a special edition titled “How China’s communist regime endangered the world” to unsuspecting houses across the English-speaking world, including my own apartment in Sydney. It alleges that Covid-19 could, this is the important part legally-speaking, and only could, have been manufactured by a Chinese laboratory and unleashed onto the city of Wuhan by accident, a slightly more palatable take on an established QAnon conspiracy theory.
Beyond that, the “newspaper,” if it can even be called that, has increasingly started to support Trump’s campaign for re-election, at the very least because he promises to be “tough on China” but more likely because of its dubious financial connections, having received donations from Robert Mercer as well as turning a sudden profit after peddling pro-Kremlin pieces about the German refugee crisis.
So, you see, seeing them there in Hyde Park that July, only days after returning from Hong Kong and mere weeks after the tear gas first started flying, I couldn’t help but feel that they had been right to warn us about China. That the CCP had come for them first, Hong Kong next, and would for everyone else soon enough. I felt relieved that there was someone else speaking for me, because my mouth was dry from telling my friends and colleagues how it felt to have become an involuntary exile, a refugee, that the country I had left behind to study and work was no longer waiting for me to return. But, despite all that, it still does not mean that the enemy of my enemy is my friend.
I can neither forgive nor forget the Falun Gong and its toe-rag for sowing disinformation and ruining lives in their pursuit for power. Though they shine a light on real problems and issues, they do so in such a way that they completely delegitimise them. Yes, the Coronavirus outbreak in Wuhan was mishandled by the government. But not because it was a rogue bioweapon or the by-product of experiments with 5-G technology, but simply because under Xi’s authoritarian regime, officials were too scared to report the truth, a familiar scenario in China’s recent history seen in chapters like the Great Leap Forward and the Cultural Revolution. The truth is that, while the Falun Gong may be correct in this instance, they are nothing more than a broken clock; their methods and motivations tarnishing the cause and doing more harm to the public than good.
I was reminded of the Falun Gong when I saw Scott Morrison and Boris Johnson condemning China for forcing through the National Security Legislation in Hong Kong, tearing up extradition treaties and offering up visas. Because they too are repeating the correct motions, acting as if they were the enemy of my enemy. But I know, at the end of the day, they’re only taking a stand because it’s convenient for them to do so, they are already embroiled in diplomatic spats with the CCP over spying claims and calls for independent audits into the Coronavirus. It’s an added benefit that Hong Kong produces the right kind of immigrants and that international travel is becoming increasingly difficult so they’re not likely to have people taking them up. But that still doesn’t mean that it was the wrong decision for them to make. The truth is that our countries do need to confront Xi Jingping’s China. The Western world has become too reliant on its sweat shops and billionaires snapping up poorly constructed properties at artificially inflated prices and we are paying the true cost for it now, our corporations, supply lines and export markets being held at ransom.
This is what the polemics between the Falun Gong and the CCP can teach us. That we shouldn’t discount something just because it is being said by an enemy, or accept what is being said by someone who calls themselves our ally. The Falun Gong is correct to point towards China’s human rights abuses, likewise for China to label them a cult, but they are completely wrong to suggest that Donald Trump is the antidote, the same Trump, who according to his former national security advisor John Bolton, personally approved of Xi’s plan to build concentration camps, and who, when the Hong Kong protests first broke out, insisted that he didn’t want to get involved because the United States had its own human rights problems too, an ominous statement that has been confirmed in the responses to the Black Lives Matter movement in recent weeks.
We see it even here in Australia, with the crucifixion of Dan Andrews for problems caused by Scott Morrison, Peter Dutton and Gladys Berejiklian’s bungling of the Ruby Princess and abdication of all federal responsibilities for borders, and the continued insistence by Sky News that this is only a Chinese virus. The sad truth is that everything is flawed and complicated, and that every major power is looking for a scapegoat to distract from their own ills. But that still doesn’t mean that everything is equally so. There are always degrees of damage and danger. It is why the United States and USSR were allied during World War Two when there was a larger threat on the horizon, and as we know, it didn’t mean that they weren’t enemies themselves.
I’d like to believe that Shorten or Corbyn would all be exercising condemnation in alternate universes where idiocy, fear and xenophobia didn’t prevail, but for now must resign myself to taking what I can get, the broken clock, and acknowledging that the Liberals and Tories have done something good for the people of Hong Kong in taking a stand, as ineffectual or tokenistic as it might be. Does it make up for the damage that they have caused their countries? Of course not. But we can’t look at it through the lens of partisanship as many opposed to the government are prone to do, to assume that because it was they, the Right wing that did it, that it must be wrong.
I am reminded of a conversation I had with a colleague after last year’s shocking election result. They said that democracy was doomed and that we would all be better off if we followed in China’s footsteps. I know that her heart was in the right place, but I couldn’t have disagreed with her any further, because I had seen how China treated its people first hand, the clampdown of 2014 and the meddling both before and after. I’d like to believe that the last year has shown us all why that can’t ever be an option, and why we must fight against misinformation and propaganda wherever it comes from, to weigh up our options and not just blindly align ourselves with people because of a single issue that is important to us. Why, if that were the case, I’d be out in Hyde Park now, meditating and handing out fliers.
